How investment banks can build a VDR proof-of-concept process
Selecting a virtual data room (VDR) is often treated as a procurement decision. Investment banks review security certifications, compare product demonstrations and assess pricing before selecting a platform for an upcoming transaction. Yet a successful demonstration does not necessarily establish whether the technology can support the bank's actual diligence requirements.
The difference becomes apparent when multiple bidders require different document permissions, questions arrive simultaneously and a transaction deadline leaves little room for technical problems.
Rather than relying exclusively on vendor presentations, investment banks should establish a repeatable proof-of-concept (POC) process that tests how a VDR performs against realistic M&A scenarios.
The objective is not to identify the platform with the longest feature list. It is to establish measurable evidence that the platform can support the bank's transaction requirements.
Start with transaction requirements, not vendor features
A meaningful VDR proof of concept begins by identifying the operational risks associated with the bank's typical transactions.
A competitive sell-side auction may prioritize bidder confidentiality, Q&A routing and engagement reporting. A cross-border acquisition may place greater emphasis on data residency, multilingual support and regulatory requirements.
These differences should determine the testing scenarios rather than allowing vendors to define the evaluation around their strongest capabilities.
Before testing begins, the investment bank should involve deal execution, information security, legal, compliance and procurement stakeholders. Each function should identify its requirements and distinguish mandatory controls from capabilities that improve efficiency.
For example, independently verified security documentation and appropriate access controls may be prerequisites, while advanced reporting features could receive weighted scores.
This approach creates a consistent evaluation framework without assuming that every transaction has identical needs.
Establish measurable acceptance criteria
The most important improvement investment banks can make to VDR procurement is replacing subjective impressions with documented acceptance criteria.
A requirement such as "supports granular permissions" is insufficient because it does not specify how the capability should perform.
A stronger acceptance test might require an administrator to restrict a sensitive document to one bidder group, verify that another group cannot access it and confirm that the resulting permission changes appear in the activity record.
Similarly, a Q&A requirement should specify whether questions can be assigned to subject-matter experts, reviewed before publication and restricted to the appropriate participants.
Each test should have an expected outcome, a designated reviewer and a documented result.
Banks can classify results as passed, failed or requiring remediation. Mandatory security or confidentiality failures should prevent approval until the issue is resolved and retested.
A repeatable framework makes vendor comparisons more defensible because every platform is assessed against the same operational expectations.
Simulate a live M&A diligence environment
A VDR proof of concept should recreate a representative transaction rather than rely on a vendor's prepared demonstration environment.
The bank can use a sanitized document set containing financial statements, commercial agreements, employment materials and other documents commonly exchanged during diligence.
Test participants should represent different roles, including administrators, seller representatives, bidder advisors and legal reviewers.
The evaluation should examine how the platform handles document uploads, indexing, restricted access and changes to bidder permissions.
A particularly useful scenario involves promoting a bidder to the next auction round while keeping commercially sensitive materials unavailable to other participants.
The bank should verify both the intended access and the absence of unintended access.
Platforms such as Intralinks VDRPro™ provide secure environments for transaction document sharing. However, the relevant controls should still be tested against the bank's own permission structure and disclosure requirements.
A successful test demonstrates not only that authorized users can complete their work, but also that unauthorized activity is prevented.
Test workflows, AI capabilities and reporting together
Individual features may work well during demonstrations but create operational friction when combined into a live diligence process.
Investment banks should therefore test the complete workflow, beginning with document requests and continuing through uploads, Q&A, approvals and reporting.
For example, a test could require several bidder representatives to submit questions simultaneously. Administrators would then route those questions to appropriate experts, review proposed answers and release approved responses without exposing confidential bidder information.
AI-assisted search should also be evaluated using representative documents and specific questions with known answers.
The bank should assess retrieval accuracy, identify unsupported outputs and determine where human verification remains necessary.
Intralinks DealCentre AI™ supports connected deal preparation, diligence and management activities. Its capabilities can be assessed within the broader workflow rather than as isolated product features.
Reporting tests should confirm whether deal teams can retrieve the information needed to understand document activity, outstanding requests and bidder engagement.
The result should be a practical assessment of workflow reliability, not simply a demonstration that individual features exist.
Verify integrations, records and support readiness
A VDR operates within a broader transaction technology environment, making integrations and recordkeeping important parts of acceptance testing.
Where required, banks should test authentication, user provisioning, document exports and connections to existing systems.
Legal and compliance stakeholders should also review whether the platform can produce the activity records and transaction archives required by the engagement.
These tests should verify the contents and usability of exported records, not merely confirm that an export function exists.
Support readiness deserves equal attention. Banks should test how issues are reported, escalated and resolved, particularly when participants operate across different time zones.
For workflows involving ongoing document requests and bidder coordination, DealCentre AI diligence capabilities may be relevant to the evaluation.
Service commitments, escalation procedures and responsibilities should be documented before a platform receives final approval.
Turn testing results into a repeatable procurement standard
A proof of concept becomes more valuable when its findings inform future technology decisions.
Investment banks should maintain a standardized evaluation record containing test scenarios, acceptance criteria, results, identified limitations and remediation outcomes.
Mandatory controls should be evaluated separately from weighted capabilities such as reporting efficiency or administrative convenience. This prevents strong performance in less critical areas from compensating for unresolved security or confidentiality concerns.
The final decision should involve the stakeholders responsible for operating the platform and managing the associated risks.
For banks executing multiple transactions, the framework can be reused and adapted to different deal structures, reducing the need to recreate the evaluation process for every mandate.
A disciplined VDR proof of concept turns vendor selection from a feature comparison into an evidence-based operational decision.
That approach helps investment banks select technology with greater confidence while establishing clear expectations for performance before a transaction begins.
FundCentre™
Explore our AI-enabled platform designed to keep you connected with integrated solutions.
DealServices™
Learn how our redaction, translation and NDA services save time and resources.